| All Reviews > mbaMission Reviews |
Product mbaMission School Package
Consultant Susan McInerny
Strengths:
Support throughout the whole process, wealth of various resources, high level of service
Would make the product better:
N/A
I cannot recommend Susan enough—if you’re looking for an MBA consultant, she’s truly the best! After several free consultations with other consultants (one during which the consultant made me cry), I immediately connected with Susan during our first conversation and knew she was "the one." I came in unsure of how to tell my story, and within 10 minutes, she helped me craft a compelling narrative about why I was pursuing my MBA.
Throughout the entire process, it was clear that Susan genuinely cared—not just about me, but about each of her students. She took the time to deeply understand my background and goals, and the level of thoughtfulness and care she brought to every draft, phone call, and email was beyond anything I expected. Sometimes I honestly wondered how she balanced so many students with the level of personal attention she gave me.
Despite my lower GMAT score and thanks to Susan’s incredible guidance, I was accepted into a few top-tier programs and will be heading to UChicago Booth this fall! I feel incredibly fortunate to have worked with her and know that she will remain a lifelong friend and mentor.
Product mbaMission School Package
Consultant Katharine Lewis
It’s a difficult task to be able to summarize an entire business school application process into a single testimonial; it’s an even more challenging task to distill a person’s entire breadth of personal and professional experiences into a series of compelling essays and short answer questions that sneak in just under a restrictive word limit. Katy was able to masterfully do just that, and then some.
On paper, I come from a very traditional and overrepresented professional background when it comes to business school applicants (investment banking / private equity). But I also had a lot of unique and seemingly unrelated interests and experiences that I, at least, hoped could differentiate me if I could figure out how to actually tell them. That was always my biggest anxiety when setting out to begin my application process: I had a complicated story that risked being “all over the place” and incoherent if told incorrectly. I was also on the fence about working with an admissions consultant having never worked with one before. I did introductory meetings with around 10 consultants across a number of firms and none were quite able to see the “real me” behind the traditional background quite like Katy was. I met with Katy twice, but I knew after our first 30-minute intro call that I wanted to work with her. I felt like she was really able to “see” me and my story, which was an immediate weight off of my shoulders.
I won’t shortchange the difficulty of the application process, but Katy really did a wonderful job segmenting it into “digestible” bites to tackle, and she staged it in a way such that I never felt overwhelmed or behind schedule, even with an extremely demanding job. Pretty quickly, Katy was able to masterfully weave a series of disparate an unrelated experiences into a single, cohesive narrative, plucking the right threads from each in a way that I know I would have struggled to do on my own. This, alone, made the whole experience of working with her worth it for me. But it didn’t stop there; Katy was always available to answer my one-off questions and pull form her experience having sat on the “other side of the table” at Stanford. I very much valued her opinion and guidance when it came to the process-related questions and with how to best position my application.
When it was all said and done, I applied to Harvard, Stanford, and Wharton, I was invited to interview at all three, and I was admitted to 2 of the schools and waitlisted at the third. While I am obviously ecstatic with the outcome, before hearing back from the schools I was actually quite calm. I knew that, regardless of what the outcome would be, that I had put my best foot forward. And I knew that, with Katy’s help, I was able to put together an application that I was really happy with and confident in submitting. I am fairly certain that I would have had neither the smooth application process nor the outcome that I did without Katy’s help. For that, I will be forever grateful.
Product mbaMission Hourly Services
Consultant Michael Guttman
I'd recommend working with Michael to as many people as I can. If you're serious about increasing your chances of getting into your dream school, reach out to Michael and work with him. He consistently made himself available on short notice and was always well prepared with advice and guidance.
Michael's consulting and guidance through the application and interview process was nothing short of amazing. I could not have achieved the success in my applications that I did without his help and counsel.
He was exceptional in his advice for essay improvement as well as mock interviews.
Product mbaMission School Package
Consultant Susan McInerny
I met Susan after experiencing a devastating rejection from HBS following an interview. This was my third attempt at top-tier schools, and needless to say, I was feeling defeated. However, Susan’s approach was a game-changer. She was incredibly patient, offering a fresh perspective on my story. She took the time to review all my past applications—something my previous counselor didn’t do—including those from 2019 deferred admission applications.
Susan went above and beyond to understand my long-term plans and truly pinpoint what I wanted the admissions teams to know about my journey. She helped me refine both my short- and long-term goals, crafting essays that resonated with the values of HSW. While I didn’t gain admission to HBS, I did secure interviews at GSB and Wharton, thanks to her guidance.
What stood out the most was how accessible and supportive Susan was. Whether it was through emails or late-night phone calls when I was overwhelmed, she was always there, providing calm, thoughtful advice. She even went the extra mile by advising me on what other schools were looking for in essays and interviews, even though she had no obligation to do so. Thanks to Susan’s expertise and unwavering support, I received offers from 9 colleges including CBS, Booth, and Kellogg, was waitlisted at 4, and had only one rejection.
When it came time to make my decision, Susan was again instrumental. She was candid and insightful, helping me evaluate the cultures of the campuses and guiding me toward the right fit. In fact, she knew which school I’d choose before I even realized it myself!
As for the waitlist process, I cannot emphasize enough how crucial Susan’s support was. After being waitlisted by MIT, Wharton, and GSB and facing the added challenge of losing my job, Susan provided invaluable support in helping me craft compelling updates to strengthen my applications. Her guidance during this difficult time was crucial.
In conclusion, I wholeheartedly recommend working with Susan. She genuinely cares about her clients, takes the time to understand them, and builds meaningful connections. I’m confident that even though my MBA application journey has ended, I’ll stay in touch with Susan for years to come. She truly is amazing, and I wouldn’t be where I am today without her.
REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]
Product mbaMission School Package
Consultant Susan McInerny
Strengths:
All inclusive, unlimited access to super insightful consultant
Would make the product better:
N/A
Working with Susan was one of the best decisions I made during the application process. I truly believe I wouldn’t be where I am without her insight, guidance, and unwavering support.
From day one, Susan went above and beyond. She knows my target program inside and out, and guided me through every step with clarity and confidence—from early brainstorming to interviews and even after admission results were announced. She was always just a message away and consistently made herself available to review materials and emails, provide thoughtful feedback, or help me work through decisions. For someone unfamiliar with the process, that level of accessibility and reassurance made a world of difference.
What truly sets Susan apart is how deeply she invests in getting to know you. She doesn’t just focus on your resume or career milestones—she genuinely takes the time to understand who you are as a person. She asked thoughtful questions and really listened, which allowed us to craft an application that felt both authentic and compelling. That personal connection showed through in my materials, and I believe this is a true differentiator as it helped my story resonate with the admissions team on a deeper level.
Susan also supported my recommenders—both seasoned executives—with tailored guidance that they found incredibly helpful. They both told me how much they appreciated her insight in helping them understand what the school is truly looking for and how to best frame their recommendations, making the process more strategic and focused.
I feel incredibly fortunate to have had the opportunity to work with Susan. She’s thoughtful, respectful, and genuinely committed to your success. Most of all, she’s someone you can trust to walk with you through what can be a very personal and high-stakes journey. I can’t recommend her highly enough.
Product mbaMission School Package
Consultant Jessica Shklar
Strengths:
When I began my MBA journey, I was filled with uncertainty. I had a vague idea of my post-MBA goals, but I struggled to connect my past experiences to a compelling narrative. On top of that, I was unsure which schools were the right fit for me and how to navigate the complex application landscape.
That’s where Jessica came in. After speaking with more than 10 consultants, I immediately knew she was the one after our first call. Jessica’s energy, genuine interest in my story, and deep knowledge of the U.S. MBA landscape reassured me that I was in the right hands. Without hesitation, I decided to work with her—and it was the best decision I made.
From day one, Jessica took the time to deeply understand my personal and professional background, career aspirations, and even my family values. She seamlessly wove all of these elements into my MBA applications, creating a cohesive and compelling narrative. Her expertise in storytelling was invaluable—reading my final applications, I could clearly see the impact she had in helping me craft a powerful and authentic story.
Beyond her professional guidance, Jessica provided unwavering emotional support. The MBA application process is grueling, especially when applying to multiple schools. She consistently reminded me to trust the process, keeping me motivated and focused.
Thanks to Jessica, I was accepted into Columbia Business School—one of my dream schools from the very beginning. If you’re about to embark on your MBA journey, look no further than Jessica. She is truly a game-changer.
Would make the product better:
Nothing
When I began my MBA journey, I was filled with uncertainty. I had a vague idea of my post-MBA goals, but I struggled to connect my past experiences to a compelling narrative. On top of that, I was unsure which schools were the right fit for me and how to navigate the complex application landscape.
That’s where Jessica came in. After speaking with more than 10 consultants, I immediately knew she was the one after our first call. Jessica’s energy, genuine interest in my story, and deep knowledge of the U.S. MBA landscape reassured me that I was in the right hands. Without hesitation, I decided to work with her—and it was the best decision I made.
From day one, Jessica took the time to deeply understand my personal and professional background, career aspirations, and even my family values. She seamlessly wove all of these elements into my MBA applications, creating a cohesive and compelling narrative. Her expertise in storytelling was invaluable—reading my final applications, I could clearly see the impact she had in helping me craft a powerful and authentic story.
Beyond her professional guidance, Jessica provided unwavering emotional support. The MBA application process is grueling, especially when applying to multiple schools. She consistently reminded me to trust the process, keeping me motivated and focused.
Thanks to Jessica, I was accepted into Columbia Business School—one of my dream schools from the very beginning. If you’re about to embark on your MBA journey, look no further than Jessica. She is truly a game-changer.
REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]
Product mbaMission School Package
Consultant Jen Kedrowski
Would make the product better:
Nothing :-)
I got into my dream school and I truly can’t thank Jen enough!
I met Jen for the first time through a "ding review" a couple of years ago, when I had applied and didn't get in, and I was feeling pretty dejected. But Jen’s thoughtful feedback helped me understand the weaknesses in my application while giving me confidence that I had a strong foundation to build on. From that moment, her guidance was instrumental in every step of my journey.
One of the most impactful parts of working with Jen was our brainstorming calls. She helped me reflect deeply—on my childhood, how I grew up, the choices I made, and the values that matter most to me. These conversations gave me a rock-solid foundation for all my application and ensured that my story was deeply personal and compelling.
Her feedback on my essay was especially invaluable. Given how unique this school's essay prompt is, I had been thinking about it for months before I even started writing. It required intense self-reflection to articulate what truly matters most to me and why. Jen kept pushing me—gently but persistently—until my voice came through clearly and authentically. That process made all the difference.
When it came time for interviews, Jen’s mock interview sessions were a game-changer. She covered a wide range of questions, challenged me to think on my feet, and helped me get a feel for how the real interview would go. She pointed out key areas to prepare for but also ensured I didn’t over-prepare. You want to be authentic and conversational in the interview. Thanks to her, I walked into my interview with confidence and clarity.
Jen’s ability to guide while ensuring I stayed true to myself was remarkable. What sets Jen apart is her ability to nudge you in the right direction without ever making the process feel forced or unnatural. She helped me tell my story in a way that felt genuine, compelling, and true to who I am. Her feedback was always precise, insightful, and—above all—and I could feel how much she truly cared. It was clear that she was just as invested in my success as I was. If you’re looking for an MBA consultant who will help you craft the best possible application without losing your authenticity, I can’t recommend Jen highly enough.
Product mbaMission School Package
Consultant Harshad Mali
First and foremost, I truly do not believe I would be in the position of holding three admits—from HBS, Wharton, and MIT Sloan—without Harshad’s guidance and support throughout the application process. From day one, Harshad was realistic about how competitive these schools are, but also incredibly encouraging and pushed me to bring my best to every part of the process.
We started with a 20+ page brainstorming document, and while that felt daunting at first, Harshad’s approach helped me refine my story in a way I never could have done on my own. He has an incredible eye for identifying what makes someone stand out—often drawing attention to experiences or insights I had initially overlooked. What I had dismissed as “just part of the job,” Harshad helped me shape into compelling, differentiated narratives.
One of the qualities that makes Harshad an exceptional coach is his honesty and commitment to high standards. He was never one to sugarcoat feedback or just tell me what I wanted to hear. When an essay wasn’t landing, he told me directly—but he also jumped on calls, worked through the ideas with me, and never let me settle for “just okay.” That combination of candor and support is rare and exactly what I needed.
On top of all that, Harshad was incredibly responsive and dependable. With a demanding job and three top-tier applications to juggle, I can’t overstate how much it helped to have a coach I could count on for fast, thoughtful feedback—often within just a few hours.
Before I started the journey, I hesitated about making the investment in the three-school package. Like many others, I had some sticker shock. But now, on the other side with three dream admits in hand, I can say without hesitation: it was 100% worth it. I wouldn’t have achieved these results without Harshad, and I’m incredibly grateful for his partnership every step of the way.
If you’re on the fence, my advice is simple: go for it. I couldn’t recommend MBA Mission—and Harshad specifically—more highly.
REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]
Product mbaMission Hourly Services
Consultant Harold Simansky
Strengths:
Harold is truly exceptional. His deep knowledge of the MBA admissions process, strategic thinking, and ability to personalize advice to your unique background make him an invaluable partner. He listens carefully, challenges you in the right ways, and helps you tell your story in a powerful, authentic way. His feedback is thoughtful, fast, and always on point—he’s detail-oriented without ever losing sight of the big picture.
Would make the product better:
Honestly, nothing. Harold exceeded all my expectations and I can’t think of a single thing I’d change. He’s everything you’d want in an MBA admissions counselor—and more.
Working with Harold from mbaMission was easily one of the best decisions I made in my MBA journey. From day one, Harold brought not just deep knowledge of the MBA admissions landscape but also unmatched strategic insight, empathy, and a genuine belief in my story.
He helped me crystallize my goals, connect the dots across my personal and professional experiences, and uncover narratives I didn’t even realize were powerful. Harold never rushed me. He listened deeply, challenged me thoughtfully, and pushed me to dig deeper when it mattered most. He provided detailed essay feedback, sometimes turning around edits within hours, and always with comments that elevated my writing without losing my voice.
Beyond essays, Harold guided me through school selection, interview preparation, resume reviews, recommender strategy, and even navigating waitlists and post-interview follow-ups. He was always one step ahead with a clear plan, personalized advice, and genuine encouragement that kept me motivated through every high and low.
Thanks to Harold, I ended up with multiple M7 offers and most incredibly, a full ride to Wharton. I truly could not have done it without him.
If you are even thinking about applying to business school, do yourself the biggest favor and work with Harold. He is not just a counselor. He is a game changer.
Product mbaMission Hourly Services
Consultant Gavriella Semaya
I first reached out to Gavriella through the free 30-minute call offered by MBA Missions. From that very conversation itself, I could see her passion for genuinely helping candidates. She took the time to understand my background and aspirations—even though we hadn’t formalized anything—and she never hesitated to guide me. Following our call, she sent me a detailed action plan outlining the next steps to improve my profile.
Despite not signing on, she continued to check in consistently, offering personalized advice every step of the way. Her willingness to share her time and expertise with no expectation in return truly set her apart.
I distinctly remember when I was uncertain about whether to retake my GMAT. Gavriella calmly explained that the GMAT was only one part of my application and reassured me that my score was strong enough. She helped me see the bigger picture—encouraging me not to waste time retaking the GMAT, but rather to focus on my application materials.
One aspect that particularly stood out was her proactive approach. When I shared my admission results with her, she suggested I use my offers strategically to negotiate scholarships—a strategy I hadn’t seriously considered until she mentioned it. She even offered to review several drafts of my application materials, providing thoughtful, pointed feedback that made my writing clearer and more compelling.
Although I eventually ended up at an M7, I truly believe that if I had worked with Gavriella through a full school package, my results could have been even more impressive—potentially securing offers from additional top programs with scholarships on the table. For anyone at the stage of choosing an admissions consultant, I highly recommend investing in expert guidance. Gavriella’s insights, empathy, and strategic thinking make her an outstanding MBA coach.
I wholeheartedly recommend Gavriella to anyone on their MBA journey. Her honesty and genuine passion for helping candidates shine through in everything she does—even when there’s no transaction involved—that says it all.